Health beat

Was Susan Boyle released from the hospital too soon?

boyle_136[1].jpg
Susan Boyle on May 8
Photo: bauer-griffin
mental_boyle_136[1].jpg
Susan Boyle on June 5
photo: ap images
Less than a week after being hospitalized for "exhaustion" and a reported "nervous breakdown", Susan Boyle has reportedly been released. To understand what she might be going through, and whether she's getting the best care, we spoke with Srinivasan Pillay, M.D., Assistant Clinical Professor of Psychiatry at Harvard Medical School and a clinical associate at McLean Psychiatric Hospital in Belmont, Massachusetts.

"Coming back too soon and too fast can be dangerous, if a person is exposed to a stressful situation without treatment in place," says Dr. Pillay. What is too fast, of course, depends on the individual, he says, "but a reasonable estimate is to try to diminish exposure to high-levels stresses for two to four weeks after the initial event. Afterwards, you can expose yourself to a lower-stress environment, while remaining in contact with your therapist, so before and after the event you can process what's been happening."


While only Susan Boyle's doctors can comment on her specific medical condition, the extreme anxiety reaction to sudden media exposure is a common phenomenon. "When a person has significant public exposure, a number of stressors can lead to an extreme state of discomfort," says Dr. Pillay. "There can be an escalating sense of expectations, internal pressure to perform, embarrassment at not achieving goals, and at exposing a part of oneself that one didn't expect to expose publicly." The level of media exposure can determine whether common performance anxiety turns into an anxiety disorders--defined as a condition that disturbs social and occupational functioning. These anxiety disorders can range from "adjustment disorders," in which symptoms disappear within six months, to "social phobia," a more serious condition in which one is afraid to go out in public, to "generalized anxiety disorder," a still more serious condition.  "It makes a difference whether you're exposed to two people, or 50, or 50 million," says Dr. Pillay.  "Celebrity exposure often leads to stress-related symptoms, which may or not fall within psychiatric syndromes." Performance anxiety, for example, is not a psychiatric condition, but social phobia and generalized anxiety disorder are.

Ironically, the best  treatment for people with anxiety disorders is often to return to the original cause of stress fairly soon--but not too soon, and only under professional care. Some medications, such as beta-blockers, can help calm an individual down to the degree they can perform again in a controlled environment, which builds confidence and sets the stage for a recovery. Other medications take several weeks to take effect. One of the most effective treatments is a "talk" therapy, often conducted in concert with medications: Cognitive Behavior Therapy, in which the individual is exposed to the stressor (fear of heights, for example) in graded increments and helped to reframe her thoughts ("no, my heart beating so fast doesn't mean I'm having a heart attack, this is just my anxiety").

But it can't happen too soon-or without professional help.

So perhaps after a few weeks of medical and cognitive-behavioral therapy, Susan Boyle might benefit from a small concert. She could work with her therapist, both before and afterwards, to recover her confidence and learn to control anxiety symptoms. Then she can move on to bigger stages.

Whether she'll have the opportunity to travel that healthy path is another question. "I highly recommend treatment for anxiety disorders because they are so treatable," says Dr. Pllay. "And treatment can significantly improve one's quality of life."

To learn more:

Five Ways to Stop Negative Thinking

Are My Moods Normal?

Get more updates by following us on Twitter

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Was Susan Boyle released from the hospital too soon? .

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://healthbeat.yourtotalhealth.com/system/mt-tb.cgi/47574

1 Comments

Stephanie said:

I completely agree, and am afraid that being released so soon, she does not have enough time to heal. The roller coaster that has been her journey over the past few months is one not fathomable by the average person. Though hungry for fame and success even the most ambitious I think would crumble in dealing with so much stress. Deciding to leave treatment early to care for her cat seems questionable. I think it's important to make sure you can care for yourself before you care for others -- and that includes pets.

It’s funny and unfortunate, that while we live in an age of female enlightenment, we are so unenlightened about long term emotional management for women.

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

* - mandatory fields. ** - We do not collect Emails but for verification purposes valid email must be provided