Q&A: Does Tofu Have Too Much Estrogen for a Teenager?
Q: My daughter is 13-years-old and has decided to be a vegetarian. My friend said she was too young to eat much tofu - because it has too much estrogen in it! Is this true?
Do you have any other tips for her to follow? She doesn't like many veggies, and thus ends up eating a lot of carbs/fats.
A: Many teenagers - just like your daughter - experiment with their food choices, and opt for a "vegetarian" diet. This means different things to each person. Soy products are an excellent source of heart-healthy protein, and tofu, edamame, and other soy products should be encouraged. Soy does act as a very weak estrogen, but this is not a health minus for a young, healthy teenager (for those with a history of breast cancer, and estrogen sensitive tumors, a chat with the doctor is a must-do). As with any kind of diet, moderation is key.
You'll want to encourage your daughter to include dairy products - as she needs calcium-rich foods to support active bone growth. Skim or low-fat milk, low-fat cheese and yogurt are all important. While you can get calcium from dark green veggies, she'll need multiple cups of foods like broccoli to meet her calcium need without dairy products. Plus, eggs are a great source of protein as well. It's also a good idea for your daughter to take a daily, multiple vitamin (100% of the daily recommended intake - no super vitamins!) to round out her needs. Plenty of fruits, veggies, and some whole grains should round out her eating plan.
Let me know how your daughter is doing with her new eating strategy!
Ask Madelyn a question and look for her answers every week on HealthBeat
Visit Madelyn's Blog, Health Journal
Get more updates by following us on Twitter
Madelyn H. Fernstrom, PhD, CNS, is the iVillage Health Editor-at-Large, Diet & Nutrition Editor for the Today Show and the Founder and Director of the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center's Weight Management Center.
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Q&A: Does Tofu Have Too Much Estrogen for a Teenager?.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://healthbeat.yourtotalhealth.com/system/mt-tb.cgi/64814


Soy milk or any soy is BAD for a child!!! My almost 7yr old daughter has precocious puberty due to drinking soy milk since age 2yrs. Doctor said it is probably all the soy milk and the phyto estrogens in it. We were told to stop all soy. Stopped all soy with her for almost 40 days. Chest seems to not be growing anymore so to has body hair stopped growing. Her attitude has changed dramatically!!!! She was a hell child before. She has been so calm and even and not having major tantrums involving hitting and kicking. She has been good for the same amount of time she has been off the soy milk....Why?...NO MORE ESTROGEN IN HER SYSTEM!!! Doctor said it was like we were giving her a birth control pill every day. This may be OK for a 13yr old but definitively NOT 6yr. old. Don't trust the person above! Ask your own doctor, naturopath, supplement store, and do YOUR own research
Sure thing, if you are searching for a book, it is better to use special search engines only on ebooks. But as it turns out, there also exist search engines on ebooks formats!
I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.
Alena
http://ovarianpain.net